Blog
From impact man­age­ment to dis­clo­sure:  the TISFD and IMM­PACT Guide

In this inter­view, Jonas Fathy explains what the TISFD means for Germany’s impact ecosys­tem, why mean­ing­ful impact man­age­ment should come before dis­clo­sure, and how the IMM­PACT Guide helps orga­ni­za­tions define, man­age, and strate­gi­cal­ly inte­grate social impact.


Jonas Fathy, Head of Phil­an­thropy & Non­prof­its at PHI­NEO

The Task Force on Inequal­i­ty and Social-relat­ed Finan­cial Dis­clo­sures (TISFD) is prepar­ing to release a glob­al frame­work to help com­pa­nies and investors sys­tem­at­i­cal­ly assess and trans­par­ent­ly dis­close social inequal­i­ties, risks, and impacts.

Hi Jonas, what is the TISFD, and why does it mat­ter right now?

Jonas Fathy: TISFD stands for Task Force on Inequal­i­ty and Social-relat­ed Finan­cial Dis­clo­sures. This UN-ini­ti­at­ed task force is devel­op­ing a glob­al, ini­tial­ly vol­un­tary frame­work for com­pa­nies, finan­cial insti­tu­tions, and investors to report on how their activ­i­ties relate to inequal­i­ty and oth­er social issues.  While it for­mal­ly tar­gets major mar­ket play­ers, its reach also extends to their invest­ments and sup­ply chains.

This frame­work is par­tic­u­lar­ly rel­e­vant right now because it brings social issues into sharp­er focus. Inequal­i­ty, work­ing con­di­tions, and access to essen­tial ser­vices direct­ly affect val­ue cre­ation, resilience, and invest­ment deci­sions.  This makes social impact a key con­sid­er­a­tion for busi­ness deci­sions – not just in report­ing, but also in gov­er­nance, strat­e­gy, and risk man­age­ment.

It’s impor­tant not to under­es­ti­mate the TISFD’s influ­ence sim­ply because the frame­work is vol­un­tary.  It is designed to align with inter­na­tion­al report­ing stan­dards and, lpo­ten­tial­ly, Euro­pean sus­tain­abil­i­ty report­ing require­ments.  The task­force is con­duct­ing con­sul­ta­tions world­wide and devel­op­ing its frame­work with input from a wide range of stake­hold­ers across busi­ness, gov­ern­ment, and civ­il soci­ety. PHI­NEO is also a mem­ber of the TISFD Alliance.

Per­haps most impor­tant­ly, the TISFD builds on an estab­lished approach.  It fol­lows the TCFD and TNFD, which focused on cli­mate-relat­ed and nature-relat­ed issues, respec­tive­ly. Their frame­works have sig­nif­i­cant­ly influ­enced legal­ly bind­ing require­ments, includ­ing the EU’s Cor­po­rate Sus­tain­abil­i­ty Report­ing Direc­tive (CSRD).  In oth­er words, what starts as a vol­un­tary frame­work today is very like­ly to shape manda­to­ry require­ments in the future .

Why should star­tups pay atten­tion to the TISFD?

Jonas Fathy: Although the TISFD pri­mar­i­ly tar­gets larg­er mar­ket play­ers, star­tups can ben­e­fit from engag­ing with it as well.  The frame­work rais­es a fun­da­men­tal ques­tion: Which social risks and oppor­tu­ni­ties are tru­ly mate­r­i­al to your busi­ness mod­el? Star­tups that address this ques­tion ear­ly can make bet­ter strate­gic deci­sions, man­age their impact more effec­tive­ly, and avoid hav­ing to make adjust­ments lat­er on.

The same applies to investors.  The more clear­ly social impact assump­tions and poten­tial risks are defined, the bet­ter equipped investors are to make informed deci­sions and build resilient port­fo­lios over the long term.

How does the TISFD relate to the IMM­PACT Guide?  Where do their approach­es dif­fer, and how do they com­ple­ment each oth­er?

Jonas Fathy: The TISFD and the IMM­PACT Guide take dif­fer­ent but com­ple­men­tary approach­es.  The TISFD is devel­op­ing a dis­clo­sure frame­work that focus­es on how com­pa­nies address and report on social­ly rel­e­vant risks, oppor­tu­ni­ties, and impacts.

The IMM­PACT Guide starts ear­li­er in the process.  It helps com­pa­nies plan their impact inten­tion­al­ly, make their assump­tions explic­it, and estab­lish process­es for con­tin­u­ous learn­ing.  While the TISFD struc­tures how orga­ni­za­tions com­mu­ni­cate their impact exter­nal­ly, the IMM­PACT Guide strength­ens their abil­i­ty to cre­ate and man­age impact from with­in.

That’s where the two approach­es com­ple­ment each oth­er:  With­out mean­ing­ful impact man­age­ment, dis­clo­sure risks becom­ing a box-tick­ing exer­cise. With­out a clear strate­gic frame­work, impact can remain invis­i­ble.

The IMM­PACT Guide helps orga­ni­za­tions define and con­nect all aspects of Impact Mea­sure­ment & Man­age­ment: whether impact is being achieved, what that impact looks like, and how it can be mea­sured and man­aged.

Do you see any ten­sion between exter­nal report­ing require­ments and mean­ing­ful impact man­age­ment?

Jonas Fathy: Ten­sions arise when report­ing becomes an end in itself. If orga­ni­za­tions start mea­sur­ing what’s required for report­ing rather than what mat­ters to their tar­get groups and deci­sion-mak­ing, they lose sight of the pur­pose of impact man­age­ment.

But that con­flict isn’t inevitable.  The TISFD can actu­al­ly strength­en mean­ing­ful impact man­age­ment – as long as impact is treat­ed as an ongo­ing process of learn­ing and deci­sion-mak­ing mak­ing rather than some­thing to jus­ti­fy after the fact. When that hap­pens, report­ing becomes a reflec­tion of strate­gic clar­i­ty rather than an addi­tion­al bur­den.  Through the TISFD Alliance’s con­sul­ta­tion process, we’re see­ing a clear com­mit­ment to mak­ing this a pri­or­i­ty.

How does the IMM­PACT Guide align with the TISFD?

Jonas Fathy: The IMM­PACT Guide lays the ground­work for putting the TISFD into prac­tice. It helps orga­ni­za­tions clar­i­fy their impact goals, under­stand their tar­get groups, and map out their impact log­ic across out­puts, out­comes, and impact. With­out this ground­work, dis­clo­sure remains abstract.  With it, orga­ni­za­tions can sys­tem­at­i­cal­ly assess social issues and inte­grate them into gov­er­nance, strat­e­gy, and risk man­age­ment.

The IMM­PACT Guide also encour­ages orga­ni­za­tions to con­sid­er both pos­i­tive and neg­a­tive effects in their strate­gic plan­ning, be trans­par­ent about their assump­tions, and incor­po­rate the per­spec­tives of their tar­get groups. These are pre­cise­ly the ele­ments the TISFD calls for under its strat­e­gy, risk man­age­ment, and met­rics dimen­sions.

Does that mean  orga­ni­za­tions using the IMM­PACT Guide are auto­mat­i­cal­ly bet­ter pre­pared for the TISFD? And what are the lim­i­ta­tions?

Jonas Fathy: Orga­ni­za­tions that con­sis­tent­ly apply the IMM­PACT Guide are sig­nif­i­cant­ly bet­ter pre­pared – but that doesn’t mean they’ve checked every box. The Guide isn’t a dis­clo­sure frame­work or a for­mal mate­ri­al­i­ty assess­ment. Instead, it pro­vides a roadmap for devel­op­ing the strate­gic clar­i­ty need­ed to imple­ment the TISFD effec­tive­ly.

Its lim­i­ta­tions become appar­ent when it comes to detailed reg­u­la­to­ry require­ments and com­pa­ra­bil­i­ty across orga­ni­za­tions.  The IMM­PACT Guide’s strength lies in help­ing indi­vid­ual com­pa­nies build a sol­id strate­gic foun­da­tion.

Why is the TISFD rel­e­vant to impact investors, and what role does the IMM­PACT Guide play?

Jonas Fathy: For investors, the TISFD mat­ters because social risks are increas­ing­ly becom­ing finan­cial risks. Social issues that aren’t ade­quate­ly addressed can desta­bi­lize busi­ness mod­els, mar­kets, and entire port­fo­lios.  It’s also like­ly that the report­ing stan­dards being devel­oped will even­tu­al­ly become part of manda­to­ry report­ing require­ments.

When port­fo­lio com­pa­nies start using the IMM­PACT Guide ear­ly on, their impact assump­tions become more trans­par­ent, risks are iden­ti­fied soon­er, and dis­cus­sions about impact become more mean­ing­ful. This strength­ens not only their impact but also the qual­i­ty of invest­ment deci­sions.

Why should impact star­tups start using the IMM­PACT Guide today, even if the TISFD isn’t manda­to­ry for them?

Jonas Fathy: Because impact isn’t just about report­ing. It’s a reflec­tion of an organization’s val­ues and strat­e­gy. The IMM­PACT Guide helps star­tups align what they do with what they aim to achieve and approach impact as a con­tin­u­ous learn­ing process.

Start­ing today means build­ing cred­i­bil­i­ty, clar­i­ty, and stronger deci­sion-mak­ing capa­bil­i­ties – regard­less of whether or when dis­clo­sure require­ments become manda­to­ry. And if those require­ments do come into effect, star­tups will be bet­ter pre­pared to meet them effi­cient­ly.

Pho­to: © PHI­NEO / Jörg Farys